The BCCI’s decision to name Shubman Gill as the vice-captain for the ICC Champions Trophy
2025 has ignited widespread debate among cricket enthusiasts. While the young opener has
showcased exceptional form in ODIs, fans are questioning why more experienced players like
Jasprit Bumrah and Hardik Pandya were overlooked for the leadership role.
Shubman Gill’s selection appears to be a move toward grooming future leaders. At 25, he has
already cemented his place as a key player in India’s batting lineup. The selectors likely see Gill
as a long-term prospect who can gradually transition into higher leadership roles. His calm
demeanor, consistent performances, and ability to handle pressure have added to his
credentials.
However, critics argue that Bumrah and Pandya bring valuable leadership experience and are
better suited for the deputy role. Jasprit Bumrah, who led the team in the 2023 Border-Gavaskar
Trophy, is widely regarded as a leader within the bowling unit. However, his ongoing fitness
concerns have likely played a role in the decision. Though Bumrah has been included in the
Champions Trophy squad, his participation hinges on a final fitness clearance in February.
Hardik Pandya, on the other hand, has demonstrated his leadership capabilities as captain of
India’s T20I side and in the IPL. Many fans feel his experience in high-pressure matches makes
him an ideal candidate for vice-captaincy. However, his absence from the ODI squad, reportedly
due to workload management, might have been a factor in bypassing him for the role.
The decision has sparked divided opinions among fans and analysts. While some view it as a
forward-looking strategy, others believe proven leaders like Bumrah and Pandya were better
options. The effectiveness of this choice will ultimately be judged by India’s performance in the
tournament.
The BCCI’s decision to name Shubman Gill as vice-captain for the ICC Champions Trophy 2025
has sparked heated debate among fans and experts. While Gill’s rise as one of India’s most
dependable batters is undeniable, the exclusion of experienced names like Jasprit Bumrah and
Hardik Pandya from the leadership hierarchy has left many puzzled.
At 25, Gill is being groomed as a future leader. His stellar performances in ODIs, coupled with
his calm demeanor and adaptability under pressure, make him an appealing choice for the role.
The selectors appear to be investing in youth, focusing on long-term leadership development.
Gill’s appointment could be a strategic decision to ease him into a more prominent leadership
role in the coming years.
However, critics argue that players like Jasprit Bumrah and Hardik Pandya were more deserving
candidates for the position. Bumrah, India’s premier fast bowler, has shown leadership skills
during his stint as captain in the 2023 Border-Gavaskar Trophy. But his persistent injury
concerns may have worked against him. Although named in the Champions Trophy squad, his
participation is contingent on passing a final fitness test in February.
Hardik Pandya, on the other hand, has successfully led India in T20Is and proven his leadership
in the IPL. Fans feel his experience and ability to perform under high-stakes situations make
him an ideal vice-captain. However, reports suggest he has been rested from the ODI squad for
workload management, possibly influencing the selectors’ decision. Ultimately, the effectiveness
of this decision will be evaluated during India’s performance in the Champions Trophy.